TIDEZINE.

Johnny Marr on The Smiths' Breakup: Paul McCartney's "That's Bands" Became His Go-To Answer

After The Smiths split in 1987, Johnny Marr spent an entire day with Paul and Linda McCartney and walked away with one line — "That's bands" — that's served as his standard answer to the question ever since.

Johnny Marr on The Smiths' Breakup: Paul McCartney's "That's Bands" Became His Go-To Answer

In July 1987, Johnny Marr left The Smiths. Guitar duties briefly passed to former Easterhouse member Ivor Perry, but Perry didn't click with Morrissey, and by the time the Manchester legends' fourth and final album, "Strangeways, Here We Come," came out that September, the band was already effectively over.

In a recent MOJO interview, Marr looked back on that chaotic period and brought up an unexpected key figure: Paul McCartney.

Marr said he spent "a long, incredible day" with Paul and Linda McCartney. Linda was warm and kept asking about his life; when it was McCartney's turn, Marr laid out the whole story of the band's breakup. "I looked at him, waiting for a response, and all he said was: 'That's bands.'" Marr called it "a brilliant answer" — one he's pulled out ever since whenever people come to him for life advice. Sometimes, things just don't need overthinking.

That meeting was more than just a chat. In a 2012 interview with The Auto Jubilator, Marr shared details: the two never formally hit a recording studio, but spent a full eight or nine hours "just playing and playing, hard and loud." He described McCartney as "a great bass player, a great singer" — this was the first thing he did after The Smiths broke up, and "it was a happy time." The two crossed paths occasionally after that, but never played together again. "He was always very friendly, very gracious."

For Marr, that "that's bands" line ended up shaping his career choices in a way. He admitted he wasn't in a rush to form another band after the split, and was happy instead to work as a supporting guitarist for various artists: Matt Johnson of The The has been a close friend for years, and he cherished collaborations with New Order's Bernard Sumner, the Pretenders' Chrissie Hynde, and later recording sessions with Bryan Ferry. "If you wrote all that down as a résumé, it'd look like I was just drifting from gig to gig, but I knew a good job when I had one. Some things don't need overthinking."

This memory resurfaced just as The Smiths made fresh news. Earlier this month, Rough Trade announced "Rough Trade 45s: Volume 2," a vinyl box set featuring newly pressed classic singles from label acts including The Fall, Aztec Camera, Mazzy Star, Scritti Politti, and Robert Wyatt, limited to 1,000 copies and set for release on October 30. Among them is a Smiths single hand-picked by Morrissey and Marr themselves: "The Headmaster Ritual" on the A-side and "I Want The One I Can't Have" on the B-side. Both tracks originally appeared on the 1985 album "Meat Is Murder" but were never released as a single through Rough Trade — this marks their debut as a proper single.

Follow what interests you

Start with a brand tag or a section to build your own reading list.

Related

Darth Vader’s Lightsaber Resells for $4.875 Million at Heritage Auctions
Entertainment

Darth Vader’s Lightsaber Resells for $4.875 Million at Heritage Auctions

The same Darth Vader lightsaber hilt sold at Propstore in 2025. Its new sale sets auction records for Star Wars collectibles and screen-used props.

Children of Blood and Bone Returns With a New Trailer and Music From Tems
Entertainment

Children of Blood and Bone Returns With a New Trailer and Music From Tems

Paramount’s November trailer introduces the fight for Orïsha through Thuso Mbedu’s Zélie and an original song by Tems. The film opens in the US January 15, 2027.

Jean-Michel Basquiat’s Family Tells His Story in a Netflix Documentary
Entertainment

Jean-Michel Basquiat’s Family Tells His Story in a Netflix Documentary

Jean-Michel Basquiat streams December 11 on Netflix. The Tribeca award winner traces his life through family interviews, rare footage and previously unseen work.

Aston Martin Joins Star Wars for Its 50th Anniversary in 2027
Entertainment

Aston Martin Joins Star Wars for Its 50th Anniversary in 2027

Aston Martin will collaborate with Disney and Lucasfilm on Star Wars’ 50th anniversary. More details come in early 2027, and the restored 1977 film returns to cinemas in February.

Ultra Taiwan returns to Taipei on November 14 with Alan Walker
Entertainment

Ultra Taiwan returns to Taipei on November 14 with Alan Walker

Ultra Taiwan 2026 takes place at Taipei’s Dajia Riverside Park on November 14. Performances begin at noon, with Alan Walker set to close the main stage in a 75-minute set.

Chanpan Taipei tickets go on sale November 3: MOONDOG, VIP vs GA and an autogratis guide
Entertainment

Chanpan Taipei tickets go on sale November 3: MOONDOG, VIP vs GA and an autogratis guide

Chanpan plays MOONDOG in Taipei on December 3. Compare the announced GA and VIP prices and benefits, plan your arrival, and find a listening route into autogratis. Check KKTIX for current ticket information.